All your comic books are (probably) worthless

6 min read

Comics (3)

There’s a lot of great stuff to invest these days, to make certain that you have a hefty nest-egg for when you eventually retire. Gold, LEGO and low-risk stocks are all solid examples. But what about comic books? You’d imagine that with 2016 being jammed with comic book movies right now, the market must be fielding some high-value gems right now.

Like that copy of Action Comics #1, which sold for $3.2 million in 2014. Or maybe that issue of Amazing Fantasy #15, where the first appearance of Spider-Man is worth actual tens of thousands of dollars. There must be paper gold in that box at the bottom of your cupboard, right? …Man, I am about to make your easy retirement dreams crash and burn like the Hindenburg buddy.

Chances are, what you’re sitting on is barely worth its cover price these days. I’d hazard a guess, and say that your mint collection is mostly from the 1980s and early 1990s, the heyday of comic books. This was a fantastic age, one that saw hundreds of thousands of readers hit their local shop every Wednesday to pick up new issues of Batman, X-Men and more. And that’s the problem.

Comics (4)

With demand through the roof, big publishers like Marvel and DC worked overtime to ensure that there was enough of a supply. And that means that your rare first appearance of Exodus in X-Men, isn’t nearly anywhere near as valuable as you’d think. Entire runs of comics, which you’d think were worth thousands of dollars, have sold for a scant few hundred these days.

Read  Will the real Captain Marvel please stand up?

The bubble for comic book collecting swelled to an ungodly level in the 1990s, before it finally burst and crashed an entire market with enough chromium covers to cover a car show in silver. There’s just too damn many comics from that era left gathering dust in bargain bins around the world to make the hobby actually worthwhile.

Supply and demand. If you want a comic that is actually worth something, then you need to invest in something that is already rare. Like an Incredible Hulk #180 and #181 (First Wolverine appearances) or a Detective Comics (First Batman appearance) #27. These comics have value, these printed books will always have a fanbase demanding them. Good luck affording them of course.

Comics (1)

I often get asked to actually have a look at comics for possible grading, and locally, this is both amusing and heartbreaking. Flash back to when you were a kid, and South Africa was feeling the excitement of the comic book boom. All of a sudden, you could walk into a supermarket and see the likes of Lobo, the X-Men and Spider-Man. Man, surely they’re worth a few bucks, right?

Sadly, toilet paper is worth more. With comic books, there’s a perceived value at play. Collectors know what’s valuable to them, and you can’t convince them otherwise. The mid 1990s comics that we all bought into? Those were reprints of popular comics on paper that was worth less than toilet paper. I salute BattleAxe Press for making an effort to create a local market for comic books, but the low-grade reprints with Cheeto adverts at the back aren’t exactly going to get wealthy collectors frothing at the mouth.

Read  Watching the awesome opening 17 minutes of Agents of SHIELD season 5

Here’s the moral of the story: Comic books are very rarely that good of an investment these days. And there’s nothing wrong with that. What you’re paying for is a luxury that won’t hold any value in the years to come. If you want to save up for the future, start a pension fund. Comic books are about fun, gorgeous art that makes your eyes joygasm and sharp writing that thrills, entertains and delights you.


The joy of owning a comic book shouldn’t come from seeing it locked away in a CGC slab and kept out of the light. It’s about the story and loving the greatest art-form around. It’s about experiencing a level of storytelling that pushes the envelope and steers your mind towards new ideas and notions. That’s the real treat in buying a comic book. Hell, there’s nothing I like more than to actually grab a trade paperback of Preacher some days, and read one of my all-time favourite epics on a sunny afternoon.

Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to go pitch some ideas to Marvel and DC, and regret writing this column in a few years once I finally hit the big time.

Last Updated: January 27, 2016

Darryn Bonthuys

Something wrong gentlemen? You come here prepared to read the words of a madman, and instead found a lunatic obsessed with comics, Batman and Raul Julia’s M Bison performance in the 1994 Street Fighter movie? Fine! Keep your bio! In fact, now might be a good time to pray to it!

  • HvR

    The trick is to collect something that is not collectible today but will be scarce and collectible in 30 years time.

    • HouwGobz

      Non-cancerous organs?

    • Original Heretic

      Fresh water.

      • Hope for the future? tehehe

        • Hammersteyn

          XBOX Ones?

          • Jim Lenoir (Banana Jim)

            Gamer tears?

  • Nice piece Darrny. Not only do you shatter the hopes and dreams of Cosplayers in South Africa, you are now after the comic book scene. Have you no limits?!

    • I am history’s greatest monster.

      • Do you have any comics that are worth more than your promises?

        • Possibly! I have several issues of Preacher, signed by both Garth Ennis and Steve Dillion. Includes the first issue.

    • Guild

      Darren took one look at my collection then told me to use it for starting fires as it was about as worthless as a Zim dollar bill

  • Original Heretic

    Rereading Preacher is always great. Looking forward to the series, but also terrified of what they’re going to do to it.

    • Draco Lusus

      It looks like they have cocked it up already from the trailer. I’m guessing it is going to be on par with Lucifer. I watched the pilot, and it was a heap of steaming shit,

  • Alien Emperor Trevor

    When I was a wee lad I used to get my comics from the 2nd hand book shop down the road, so it was always luck of the draw when it came to finding something cool. And then of course I had to trade one in to get another. A brand new comic book was something the nobs got.

    It’s also why the ones I remember more fondly aren’t really the A-list ones like Superman or X-Men. Stuff like Spider-Woman, JSA, Creature Commandos, bunch of others.

  • Vulcha

    Smart move – make sure nobody else collects these comics so that in forty years, the ones YOU have collected are actually rare.

Check Also

Hugh Jackman comments on potential X-Men/Avengers crossover with Disney/Fox merger

With Disney's takeover of Fox's movie and TV properties seemingly set to happen any day no…