DOCTOR WHO Series 8 – Listen Review

5 min read
3

For better or for worse, Listen is a fantastic episode. It’s also a terrible episode, that will leave you slamming your head into a table in a manner reminiscent of Danny Pink having yet another bad date. Spoilers ahead…

Listen (5)

It all starts off innocently enough. The Doctor has begun pondering out aloud, of possible monsters in the dark. And with worlds filled with creatures that have evolved into the perfect predators, or the perfect escape mechanism to balance that food chain, what about a creature that has possibly evolved the most ingenius method of hiding? Kind of like the Confessors/Silence from previous Doctor Who episodes, but screw those guys, they’re already ancient Smithsonian history.

Naturally, all this leads to the Doctor roping in Clara to help him prove a point, a point that has roots all the way back to his childhood, in an adventure that goes from the end of time to the formative years of the Time Lord. And writer Steven Moffat is once again dipping into his bag of familiar tricks here, weaving a story that cements itself into the history of the show and touching back on past events.

Listen (6)

Still, criticisms of recycled ideas aside, there’s still quite a bit of fun stuff to enjoy in this episode. Clara manages to mess up her date with Danny several times in a hilariously awkward evening, the Doctor’s razor-sharp intellect finds itself baffled by a trio of make-up mirrors and the mystery itself is rather interesting thanks to a closed-loop of wibbly wobbly rummaging about in the time-stream.

Read  Here’s your first look at Doctor Who’s new Doctor outfit

Listen (1)

And then we get a glimpse at a younger Doctor, scared and alone in a barn that also doubles as the location where John Hurt’s War Doctor was ready to set off the moment way back in Day Of The Doctor. It’s a nice way to connect several dots, and even if the footage is recycled, I’ve got a soft spot for that particular incarnation of the Doctor.

And of course, we’re getting a new relationship set up between Clara and Danny, the bravest soldier without a gun. I’m only hoping that it doesn’t become as painfully corny as Amy and Rory’s romance. The biggest trick pulled out of the Moffat bag in this episode however, is that he manages to create a monster that is the exact opposite of what you expect.

It’s the sum total of all the Doctor’s fears, a figment born from what was perhaps a traumatic childhood, time-travelling and an attempt to escape being alone. It’s a monster that ties in with previous Moffat creations, with “Don’t look” being the equivalent of the Weeping Angels “Don’t blink” and the “Don’t breathe” imperative of the clockwork droids from the opening episode of the season.

Listen (7)

Of course, it’s an episode that answers questions while clumsily leaving several open, that will never ever be resolved. And that’s Listen in a nutshell. An episode with some interesting ideas, that are weighed down by some sloppy tropes from the Modern Doc Who library. As much fun as Peter Capaldi is in this episode, carrying it on his shoulders once again and saving the show and the day, expect Listen to most likely be the most polarising adventure of the season.

Read  Television will soon become local esports biggest ally

Last Updated: September 15, 2014

Darryn Bonthuys

Something wrong gentlemen? You come here prepared to read the words of a madman, and instead found a lunatic obsessed with comics, Batman and Raul Julia’s M Bison performance in the 1994 Street Fighter movie? Fine! Keep your bio! In fact, now might be a good time to pray to it!

  • I loved this episode so damn hard.

  • Kervyn Cloete

    I’m going to disagree slightly with you Darryn on two counts. Firstly, I’ve seen nothing but praise for it thus far. And secondly, to me, this is the best Doctor Who episode we’ve seen in years, and I don’t think there’s a damn thing clumsy about it. In fact, it’s very, very clever.

    Nothing was really left unanswered, as the Doctor actually gave us every answer to what was happening, right there on screen. But he kept dismissing these answers as just too mundane, and we as the audience did the same. With us, it’s because we’ve learnt to trust the Doctor’s experienced opinion on these things, but most importantly, for him, it’s because he’s too scared to admit that it might just be nothing.

    Sometimes it really is just a child under a bedspread playing a prank, or an automatic door set to unlock itself, or even a grumpy old man stealing your coffee when you’re not looking.

    This is the brilliance of this episode. You say Moffat is pulling off the same old tricks, I say he’s subverting them. We’re so used to his stories where the completely mundane is proven to actually be monstrous, and he plays with that expectation brilliantly, fooling us into buying into the lie along with the Doctor.

    Oftentimes the creepiest things out there, are what we come up with in our head. And this episode, we learn that the Doctor – even with all his wisdom and experience – is no exception to this.

    And on top of all of that, Moffat throws in some great character building between Clara and DanOrson Pink. We get just enough of a hint of her future to figure out what’s in store for her.

    And here’s totally thumbsucked theory: Dan is going to be forced by the Doctor to sacrifice himself for Clara, and thus he’ll end up in the Promised Land, which will prompt Clara and The Doctor to go after him and eventually face down Missy.

  • Milesh Bhana

    probably the best episode this season. Yes there’s some clumsiness, but i’ve really been struggling to get with the Capaldi era. Actor is awesome, but the episodes so far haven’t really been coming together, always been like the missed the mark.

    This was the first one that felt like a proper Doctor Who episode.

Check Also

Here’s your first look at Doctor Who’s new Doctor outfit

There’s a new Doctor taking over from Capaldi this year however, and with that regeneratio…