Alien: Isolation review round up

4 min read
29

AlienIsolation

Aliens: Colonial Marines was tripe, serving as a sequel to James Cameron’s Aliens – and playing like a gung-ho action shooter. Alien: Isolation from develop Creative Assembly is more of a sequel to Ridley Scott’s creepier Alien. Does it live up to that? Is it at least a better game that Colonial Marines? Well, that depends on who you ask.

Much like what happened with the (In my opinion) Excellent ZombiU on the Wii U, American reviewers seem to hate it. Those based in Europe and its colonies, or who’ve hailed from there seem to disagree, thinking it’s possibly the very best Alien game.

And honestly, I think it comes down to that fact that you don;t shoot much in it. Americans seem to favour being able to shoot out of any situation, whereas stealth and sneakiness seems to be the way to go for our European chums. From everything I’ve seen (and played), this is the perfect Alien game for me.

Here’s what critics think.

Joystiq  – 4/5

Alien

In the same way that Ash respected the alien for its brutality in the original film, though, maybe I also respect Alien: Isolation just for how long, grueling and relentless it ends up being. Instead of completing the game, it feels more like I’ve escaped it and the nightmare it put me through. I no longer have to hear the sickening slump of the alien being spewed out of a vent.

Destructoid – 8.5/10

alienbanner1

Halfway into playing Alien: Isolation, I stopped to watch the first four Alien movies again. It wasn’t just for research purposes, but mostly because the game had me yearning for more of the universe. Isolation has some flaws, but it’s faithful to the film series, and I’d love to see a follow-up with a few extra alien evolutions.

Sixthaxis – 9/10

alienbanner2

That idea of never being comfortable with how the game is unravelling is something that feels quite unique and it’s extremely well imagined here. Plenty of survival horror games have you feeling vulnerable as you essentially fulfil the role of a hero but things are different here. In Alien: Isolation you’re not the hero, you’re the prey.

The Escapist – 4.5/5
alienbanner3

Alien: Isolation can be frustrating, but it’s mostly terrifying in a near-perfect way. The Alien is scarier than it’s been since Ridley Scott first showed it to the world, and the atmosphere is thick enough to cut.

IGN – 5.9/10

alienbanner4

It may seem strange to complain that a game’s too long, but when the genuine scares of being hunted by an unstoppable predator are so diluted by repetition and padding, Isolation’s epic length really does work against it. Someday, someone is going to make an incredible Alien video game that checks every box. But, sadly, Isolation is not it.

Polygon – 6.5/10

SMILE

In the process of contriving story twists and turns to support this spectacle, Alien: Isolation ruins the unique focus of its premise and moves away from the inspiration of the first film. It becomes something depressingly predictable for fans of the property who have been hurt again and again by underwhelming video game representations. Alien: Isolation isn’t the worst Alien game, but thanks to its unrealized potential, it just might be the most disappointing.

Last Updated: October 3, 2014

Read  Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus review round-up

Geoffrey Tim

Editor. I’m old, grumpy and more than just a little cynical. One day, I found myself in possession of a NES, and a copy of Super Mario Bros 3. It was that game that made me realise that games were more than just toys to idly while away time – they were capable of being masterpieces. I’m here now, looking for more of those masterpieces.

  • Admiral Chief 0

    Hmmm, very mixed

    • Sir Rants A Lot Llew

      4 good vs 2 bad is not mixed. It’s actually good

  • FoxOneZA

    It’s like Destiny but with an Alien on your ass all the time.

  • Jac7

    Still buying it.

    • Hammersteyn

      same

    • 64bit

      me to!

      Me and Jac7 are the cool hipsters who play crap games “just cos”

      • Jac7

        Read IGN’s review. I just can’t take the reviewer seriously when his biggest complaint is that the game is too long. From what I’ve seen it looks effing awesome. If you haven’t seen it yet, check the link for the first 40 minutes of the game.

        • julian

          I think the dude says that the game dynamics don’t support a long game. He’s not saying he hates long games

  • Spaffy

    Lol IGN. Envelope not thick enough?

    • 64bit

      hehehe its funny, becos its true

  • 64bit

    ok wow if the kok sucker review mags who get paid for high scores say its crap then its utter sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet

  • Rock789

    Hopefully the sub-par reviews are just ‘mericans being ‘merican… I’ve seem some gameplay vids and it looks very atmospheric and awesomely promising. Hell, even the gameplay vids on IGN looked good and scary (and had the previewer saying it looks good). Just to be safe, I may just wait before getting hold of this one…

    • 64bit

      yeah the 1 min of footage that has been allowed to the public im sure looks amazing…

      • Rock789

        IGN had a ton of footage – over 30 minutes at one stage. Plus they then did the whole “IGN staff play Alien Isolation – is it scary?” vid, which showed some of the actual Alien encounters. Altogether, it really did look impressive. But +-40min of gameplay does not make a game… Like I said – probably gonna hold off on getting this for a while…

  • KingKappie

    SO IGN gives it a 5.9 for being to long?

    • Hammersteyn

      They are slaves to COD, goes hand in hand with a short attention span

      • Sir Rants A Lot Llew

        I want to laugh at this but unfortunately it’s true. Length = bored in todays gaming terms and that sadens me. It’s the reason games are all so short.

        Mark my words. Games are going to become one of 2 things in the future:
        1) Online for long term
        2) 2 hour “experiences” for SP.

        🙁

        • HvR

          I hate you for telling the truth.

          • RonaldoDeFranko

            🙁 🙁
            …all of that lost potential, time to listen to AHA.

  • Thami540

    I’d still hit that.

  • Sir Rants A Lot Llew

    So IGN and Polygon, what happened? Both of you complain it’s too long. Since when did being short equate to being good?

    IGN and Polygon, you guys seem to have the attention span and emotional range of a teaspoon

    • HvR

      Weird, if they said repetitive/drawn out I can see it being boring.

      • Sir Rants A Lot Llew

        They did say repetitive. But IGN is the only one who said it. It seems odd that only 1 out of all those claim it’s repetitive. I think they are just used to cod and bf style sp where the campaign is short and condensed.

    • Alien Emperor Trevor

      There’s a “that’s what she said” in there somewhere.

  • Willem Swanepoel

    Do not want to be rude here but … who the fuck cares what IGN think, they suck balls anyway .. for cash

    • HvR

      “they suck balls anyway .. for cash” they can not even do that right

  • Greylingad

    Murica!! Pew…pew… That’s disappointing… Especially that cod loving ign has such a short attention span, which is funny because they loved gta v… That reviewer is one of the worst though…

  • SNTJulio

    7,9/10 of Areajugones http://areajugones.es/alien-isolation/analisis/ (in spanish) 🙂

  • Nikola

    I stopped looking at reviews more and more Destiny had bad reviews across the board I love the game play it everyday have not put it down since it release, people that review game’s rush it as it’s their job and they have a deadline to meet so they forget about actually enjoying the game and it becomes a job to them and let’s be honest who here likes their job;) So I am very careful when it comes to reviews now days don’t really pay too much attention to them, if this game interest you get!

Check Also

Xbox One X review round-up – Microsoft’s newest console is a 4K beast

The Xbox One X is a niche device. It’s a machine for a certain market, while also requirin…