This virtual reality game about 9/11 shouldn’t be controversial

6 min read
9

The opening of [08:46]

You’re sitting at a desk in a small cornet office. Across the room a colleague of yours is talking on the phone to a client. Your computer screen is blinding bright, with pop-ups coming in thick and fast. eventually your colleague ends the call, and immediately asks you to pass her a file from your desk draw. You open it, pick up the file and walk over to hand it to her. That’s when the building shakes, the ceiling falls and everything changes.

That’s roughly what happens in what I assume are the opening minutes to [08:46] – a new virtual reality narrative game that puts you in the shoes of worker in the World Trade Centre on the morning of September 11th 2001. A day that shook the world to its core with an extreme terrorist attack on two of the most iconic buildings on this planet, and a catalyst for global conflicts that ensued shortly afterwards. So it’s understandable that people are shaking their heads at a game about it, right?

On the surface, sure. Why is there a game about 9/11? What should there be? Videogames have long been a source of escapism, but also a medium for telling interesting stories and expressing artistic emotion. This doesn’t always mean that the emotion or idea has to be one that resonate with you, and often the simple fact of not agreeing with a particular one translates to the idea of artistic censorship. It was an issue raised last year with the game Hatred – where players were tasked with committing genocide acts to rack up a score counter.

Read  Star Wars Battlefront II's loot crates still give paying players massive, game-breaking advantages

I didn’t understand it. I still don’t. But do we have the right to say it shouldn’t be made? Possibly not.

It’s a conundrum I’ve witnessed many commenters facing when researching [08:46] over the past day or so. The Twin Tower attacks might be long gone, but it’s an event that still resonates powerfully every year. It’s a wound that’s still fresh, and it’s easy for passers-by to immediately dismiss an idea of a game taking place within the horrific event. But should it? And if so why is it seemingly only videogames that are subjected to that sort of judgement?

Hatred drew lots of controversy last year

Look at a film like United 93. A heroic tale of the passengers aboard a flight that had The White House as an eventual target, all fighting back against their hijackers and saving hundreds of lives in the process. The film itself is a dramatization of events that happened, but it’s still passed as a form of entertainment that hinges on a tragedy that affected thousands of lives. If you’re willing to look back even further, Titanic does the same thing – although swapping true-life drama for a fictitious love story seems even more absurd.

Videogames aren’t strangers to exploring past tragedies in the same way though, mixing historical accuracy with enough fiction to avoid becoming accurate retellings. Call of Duty did this for years when set within the trenches of World War II – delivering players to the shores of bloody conflicts without stepping over the boundaries of showing the true horrors of the second world war. And in the process it avoided most of the criticism that a game would now attract should it feature scenes of the real atrocities – although that No Russian scene in latter titles surely attempted just that.

Read  Super Mario Odyssey review - Flawless platforming in a personality-filled package

No Russian certainly felt like something that had happened

But when I look at [08:46], I don’t see that explicit desire to attract controversy for the sake of it. The VR experience is a narrative drive one, that presumably follows what you would do in such a situation. How effective it is in conveying that comes down to how much agency it gives players, but the message itself isn’t one of implicit shock value. Instead, I interpret [08:46] as a piece of media that is meant to illicit empathy from its players. Plunging them into a horror thousands of others were left to over fourteen years ago. The same type of reaction a film like United 93 sought to obtain.

Does that make it free from criticism? Certainly not, but I think it’s important to not simply write off ideas and experiences such as this purely because of the subject matter they contain. Videogames are predominantly about entertainment, but that doesn’t mean they can’t be expression of true life hardship and serious material. In that regarded it might seem difficult to encompass it under the idea of being a game, but it’s certainly an interesting idea that I’d like to see in execution. Especially with the way in with VR is allowing us to experience digital media in a whole new, almost frightening way.

Last Updated: October 30, 2015

Alessandro Barbosa

You can all call me Sandy until I figure out how to edit this thing, which is probably never. Sandy not good enough? Call me xXx_J0k3R_360degreeN0Sc0pe_xXx. Also, Geoff’s a bastard.

  • Alien Emperor Trevor

    I have an idea: don’t call it a game. People are probably upset because it’s called a game.

    • ElNicko

      Suppose rather call it an “Experience” ??

      • Betty Black

        ???

        .…my companion’s relative makes $97 working on a PC onIine……..A few days ago new McLaren F1 subsequent after earning 18,512$,,,this was my previous month’s paycheck ,and-a little over, $17k Last month ..3-5 h/r of work a day ..with extra open doors & weekly paychecks.. it’s realy the easiest work I have ever Do.. I Joined This 7 months ago and now making over $83, p/h..Learn More right Here….
        kd.
        ??
        ??? http://GlobalEmploymentReportsTopStarJobsStep/Get/$97hourly… ?????????????????????????????????????????????????

      • Glenda Wooley

        ?

        .like Margaret answered I didn’t realize that somebody can make $25678 in 4 weeks on the web….A few days ago new McLaren F1 subsequent after earning 18,512$,,,this was my previous month’s paycheck ,and-a little over, $17k Last month ..3-5 h/r of work a day ..with extra open doors & weekly paychecks.. it’s realy the easiest work I have ever Do.. I Joined This 7 months ago and now making over $83, p/h..Learn More right Here….
        nn.
        ??
        ??? http://GlobalEmploymentAtHomeTopReportsMegaStart/Get/$97hourly… ?????????????????????????????????????????????????

  • WitWolfy

    … Play as a American killing Vietnamese/Iraqi-ans/Japanese or Russians in a historically correct game and its A-OK (FREEDOM)! Play as American getting killed in a historically correct game (Terrorism).. Geneva Convention.

    Makes me so mad!

  • Hammersteyn

    Maybe it’s more controversial because it’s based on thing that really happened unlike Hatred or MW2. I know I’d be upset if there was a VR game about how the president and ministers spend tax payers money.

    • Deceased

      WHY ARE WE NOT FUNDING THIS!!!

      • Hammersteyn

        XD

    • WitWolfy

      Confirmed!!! Malema’s “Bloody agent” DLC.

Check Also

LG V30+ Review – The best video-focused smartphone you’ll ever use

The LG V30+ was designed for a purpose. It’s not meant to be the Jack of all trades, but r…