Home Entertainment Strictly and the Sinking of British Standards

Strictly and the Sinking of British Standards

5 min read
0

Bruce Forsyth made Saturday-night television feel like an occasion. The suit, the timing and the command of a live audience suggested that entertaining the public was a serious responsibility, even when the entertainment itself was gloriously silly.

Set that beside Johannes Radebe presenting Strictly Come Dancing in a flowing gold dress, and the change in presentation is unmistakable. To my taste, the look is gaudy and self-conscious. I prefer the formal polish of the Forsyth era. Viewers should be able to say so without submitting their taste for political approval.

But the comparison reaches beyond a wardrobe. It raises a question that British institutions seem increasingly uncomfortable answering: what exactly are our standards, and who has the courage to defend them?

What British standards should mean

The values worth defending are straightforward. Take pride in your work. Respect the people paying for it. Earn your position through ability. Accept criticism. Deliver what you promised. Those expectations once formed a powerful part of Britain’s reputation. We should be angry when institutions lose sight of them.

Forsyth’s career encompassed The Generation Game, Play Your Cards Right and Strictly Come Dancing. His appeal rested on an ability to make a programme work in front of an audience. A costume could announce his arrival; keeping people entertained required judgement and experience.

That is the obligation I want the BBC to recover. Its executives should be consumed by the quality of what reaches the screen. A public broadcaster has no business treating its own sense of virtue as an achievement comparable to serving its audience well.

DEI must justify its place

The BBC’s commitment to diversity is a matter of published policy. Its 2025/26 annual report describes a Diversity, Inclusion and Belonging Strategy running to December 2027, workforce representation goals and creative diversity criteria used in commissioning.

Those policies deserve scrutiny as rigorous as any other institutional priority. Good intentions provide no exemption from questions about results. A framework does not become indispensable because its title contains words nobody wishes to oppose.

My objection to DEI bureaucracy is the competing definition of success it creates. An organisation can report progress against representation goals while leaving the public unconvinced about the quality of its work. Meeting a demographic target cannot, by itself, tell us whether a programme is funny, a presenter is effective or an institution deserves our trust.

Removing unfair obstacles to talented people is worthwhile. The case for doing that should be made through fairness and better work. It should never become a licence for managers to regard the composition of an organisation as a substitute for its performance.

Merit and performance must come first

The standard must remain demanding and universal. Appoint excellent people, give them the opportunity to succeed and judge the result honestly. A policy that cannot demonstrate how it helps that process should be changed or scrapped. Public institutions cannot afford permanent commitments sustained by fashionable language.

Strictly is a useful place to insist on that principle. It occupies a prominent place in the national schedule and trades on an inheritance of glamour, skill and familiar entertainment. The BBC should be judged on how well it preserves that appeal.

Radebe has a substantial background as a professional dancer; Radio Times documented his move into presenting. His ability as a host should face the same scrutiny as anybody else’s. Neither praise nor criticism of his performance should be settled by a photograph.

What deserves condemnation is the managerial habit of equating visible change with improvement. A new look supplies an easy announcement. An entertaining programme demands sustained work. Institutions should have to prove that their changes improve the experience of the people they serve.

An audience cannot be taken for granted

There is a serious audience challenge to address. Ofcom’s Media Nations 2026 report records declining weekly reach for broadcast television alongside growth in broadcaster viewing on demand. Streaming and changing habits help explain that shift. Those figures do not establish that DEI caused it.

They do make the BBC’s obligation more urgent. In a competitive market, a broadcaster needs an unsparing assessment of its output. Every internal priority should be tested against the work it is supposed to improve. Nothing should be protected from that examination by the fear of appearing unfashionable.

The weight of institutional bureaucracy

The same discipline belongs in the rest of public life. A council should be judged on the condition of the place it administers. A public service should be judged on whether people can depend on it. Ministers should answer for delivery. The language surrounding an institution should never be allowed to conceal the experience of dealing with it.

That is where the sinking-ship comparison has force. A struggling ship needs officers attending to the engine and the leaks. Additional reporting requirements and competing administrative goals become ballast when they absorb effort without improving the vessel. Calling that burden progressive does not make the ship more seaworthy.

My charge against DEI bureaucracy is that it risks encouraging precisely this confusion: measuring institutional virtue while the harder task of earning public confidence remains unfinished.

Demanding better from the BBC

Britain does not need another establishment fashion to tell it how enlightened it has become. It needs institutions prepared to demand excellence and explain their failures plainly. Defending those standards should require no apology.

The BBC should welcome scrutiny of its diversity policies, its appointments and its programmes. It should demonstrate how each serves the audience. Where the evidence is weak, the policy should change. Where a programme disappoints, executives should fix it. Institutions that demand public money should expect uncomfortable scrutiny.

Forsyth’s example supplies a useful discipline. Whatever happened backstage, he still had to walk out and give the audience a good evening.

British institutions should be held to an equally unforgiving test. Their ambitions, policies and publicity count for little if the public is being badly served. The public owes them no applause for good intentions.

Last Updated: November 17, 2026

Comments are closed.

Check Also

Why Competitive Gamers and Streamers Need Reliable Connection Privacy

What connection privacy means for competitive gamers and streamers, how VPNs can help, and…