Comparing Harry Potter’s Kinect Features to Move’s Sorcery

2 min read


Two soon to be released motion control systems, two magic-based 3rd person action games. One of them, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows will release on all systems, but will include Kinect-specific modes exclusive to the Xbox 360.

The other, Sorcery – a PS3 exclusive – is free from the shackles of a film licence. They both involve using motion to cast spells – but comparing them it’s pretty easy to see which uses motion control better.

Here’s the Harry Potter Kinect demo, from this week’s Gamescom :

Savvy viewers will notice that not only is it a “guided experience,” but the game often seems to be interpreting gestures in a way that’s resulting in unintended actions. It also seems to be beset by quite a bit of lag. Granted, the game probably isn’t even in a proper beta stage so flubs like that are not only excusable, they’re entirely expected.

Compared to Sorcery for PlayStation move though, it’s actually a bit laughable. While Move is essentially a shameless rip of the Wii’s controls, it’s a more mature input method that just seems more conducive to proper gaming. Besides that, it just looks like it’s more fun.

When Kinect was first announced (as Natal) I was excited. It seemed to open up a whole new way to play games. As time’s gone on – and the device has gotten closer to release I’ve become increasingly disillusioned. It seems that while Kinect may indeed offer a new way to play, it’s apparently just a new way to play games on-rails.

What I’ve come to realise is that Kinect isn’t made for people like you and me. It isn’t even made for the people who make up a large portion of the Wii demographic. It’s designed for – and is being marketed to – people who find even the Wii’s controls intimidating. I have no doubt that Kinect will get millions of people to open their wallets. It just won’t – until something suitably compelling comes along – get me to open up mine.

Last Updated: August 19, 2010

Geoffrey Tim

Editor. I'm old, grumpy and more than just a little cynical. One day, I found myself in possession of a NES, and a copy of Super Mario Bros 3. It was that game that made me realise that games were more than just toys to idly while away time - they were capable of being masterpieces. I'm here now, looking for more of those masterpieces.

Check Also

Brace yourselves, Devolver is hosting (and apologising in advance for) another “big fancy” E3 press conference

If you’re a fan of Devolver’s take on the Hyperbole machine that is E3’s press conferences…