I think I’ve been a FIFA fan since the very beginning, I can’t remember which one was my first I ever picked up but I clearly remember putting far too many hours into FIFA 96 and I’ve made sure to get my hands on every version since.

Last year I was a little disappointed with the game not kicking on and reaching the heights I expected,but in the end it got a solid 8.4 and was still technically the best FIFA released.

And now for the first time ever in a FIFA game EA Sports have included a single player story-based campaign mode where you take the reins of Alex Hunter and move up from the academy to become a superstar in world football. Well that’s the spin you get told but the reality isn’t quite as good as it sounds.

A1098-47

The Journey

My normal FIFA experience is to crack open the game and instantly enter into the single player seasons mode with my beloved Liverpool. I normally take them through 2 seasons and win the Champions League before entering the multiplayer modes and being brought back to reality with a cold, hard thump.

I’m not the best FIFA player by any stretch but I can hold my own and it’s the one game I go back to all year long until the next one is released. This year though I was more excited to get my hands on the new campaign and man oh man did I love it. The first 7 hours was amazing and I truly felt like I was this bright-eyed, up and coming superstar and was destined for greatness.

You get to show off your skills and see your ranking in the manager’s eyes increase while upping all of your personal stats. When you’ve trained enough your agent (who your grandad hates for no apparent reason) comes to you with a bunch of offers from clubs.

A1098-2

Now even though I’m a massive Liverpool fan I knew I wasn’t good enough for their team yet so I chose to join Middelsborough (MFC) to get some match time with the goal of then moving to Liverpool when the offers came in.

The first few games for MFC were good fun, I was being brought on as a substitute because I hadn’t ranked high enough yet and they had certain challenges they wanted me to meet. I played the entire Journey in player mode where you get ranked on how good your runs are, when you call for passes and which passes you choose to make.

It’s awesome seeing that real time ranking change with feedback on what the game thought you did wrong and … and well that’s where it all started falling apart really.

In the beginning I just thought I was making the wrong passing decisions or calls but after I had put in 10 hours or so I started noticing that the game wasn’t really sure what it was doing. I’d call for a nice through-ball and the player would decide against it, then dribble for a bit then turn around and then decide to try pass it. Obviously by this time I’ve moved into a new open space but he’s passing it to where I was and I’m getting punished for a bad call.

A1098-48

The same thing happens with passing where I pass a through-ball and the guy decides to not run for it and I get punished again. In the end I managed to keep my player ranking high enough to proceed by not trying anything clever at all. Just do short straight passing again and again to boost my ranking before I stop calling for the ball and let my team mates score.

It’s boring, but what was even worse than that was the knowledge that The Journey was entirely scripted. No matter how well you play it follows the same path of you being left out the team so the boss can speak to you about going on loan at a lower club. Then no matter how you do there you get called back up to the premier league and eventually into the England squad while your old friend now hates you and your old enemy is now your friend.

What I found worse though was that the commentators and voice overs were very buggy. There I was playing for Newcastle in the championship and as the game starts they start talking about what a big game this is going to be in the Premier League – with all the big name players in attendance. Then during an interview I’m being asked what it’s like playing in the Premier League, while I’m in the championship, and then being asked about my goal when I didn’t score one.

A1098-7b

It completely destroyed the feeling of realism and immersion in the game.

In the end I just wanted the games to play themselves so I could finally get to the end of the Journey which ended with a whimper.

Now don’t get me wrong, I love that EA Sports have decided to include a campaign and I’m going to be first in line next year to play the next one. But this year it’s what you would expect from a series that isn’t known for its great story-telling. EA should raid Rockstar or the now defunct Irrational games for some of their story writers.

Single Player Seasons

This is the meat and potato section of my FIFA experience over the years. The fact that FIFA has licensing for all the players, teams and stadiums has always made it a fan favourite and I never get tired of having a few virtual matches in FIFA before the big game of the weekend.

And this season is no different. All the teams are there and lovingly rendered inside their stadiums and it still brings me great pleasure to watch my family double take to see if it’s a real life match I’m watching or just a game I’m playing.

A1098-15The controls though feel like they’ve taken a step backwards. The engine behind FIFA has been changed to the Frostbite Engine this year in a move that was claimed to be required for The Journey. I secretly feel is more a push to standardise costs and development across all of EA’s games, but I digress.

The change in engine has brought with it some gameplay problems where the controls feel a little sluggish and the players don’t quite react as you’d like. But the bigger problem seems to be with the referee and the rules of the game.

For example, in the video below you can see that my guy is rugby tackled in the box in what is a blatant penalty and yet nothing was done about it. The ref just waved play on.

But it’s more than simple decisions like this which got me. In my one multiplayer match I’ve been able to play the opponent took a shot at goal and missed by a country mile. The ball flew way over the goal and yet the referee pointed to the corner. This sort of inconsistency happened far more often than was acceptable and while the latest 870Mb patch seemed to have done something to help the terrible AI it hasn’t fixed it entirely.

Multiplayer

A1098-25

Ah multiplayer, the friendship breaker; the online control smashing experience that we all love so much. In previous years I’ve loved to play the online seasons trying to work my way up to the top. I’ve never made it and normally end up around the 6th division if I recall correctly, but I’ve always loved it.

The way FIFA ranks players is probably one of the best in the business where I know that after 10 or so games I’m going to be playing against people who are around my level. That sort of experience guarantees games that are tight and exciting every time.

Or not.

I’ve been trying to play multiplayer now for a couple of days and in all this time I’ve managed to play exactly 1 game.

I don’t know what is going on but it doesn’t matter what team I choose or what controller settings I choose the game just can’t find an opponent for me. Eventually I headed to our local Facebook gaming group to see if anyone else was having the same issues.

And apparently I’m not the odd one out.

Graeme: They could be blocking SA again

This is in relation to previous multiplayer games on Xbox One having major connection issues with many of our ISP’s

Darryl: Have you checked your NAT?

This is related to your internet connection so I got hold of my ISP, organised port forwarding for everything on my line and yet still had no luck.

Joshua: Had that problem with Fifa 16 on Pc. Even with ports forwarded and everything open I could not get a game. So decided not to buy Fifa again. Enjoy the game but not being able to get matches was frustating to say the least.

Chad: The xbox one servers are naturally rubbish for fifa

Armando: Never ending story with EA! Happened the same with FIFA16 and they still can’t fix it… I’ve played 6 matches in over a year

Hmm this isn’t looking good to me, but then

Sunesh: Had that problem in FIFA 16. Keep changing the setting to find opponent based on location.

Me: Where’s that setting?

Sunesh: Customise >> Online Settings >> Matchmaking Options >> Approximate Matchmaking

So I did this and presto I found a game. Well it moved me into the waiting area where I stayed for over 5 minutes, it then joined a game and instantly quit.

I tried again and again and after many many many attempts I finally got a game.

FIFA17play

The game itself was amazing, it was a close-fought game where I went down a player and then we started scoring goals, got to 4-3 to me and then he lost a player. He scored and then in the 93rd minute with the last kick of the game he slotted another one in for a 5-4 win.

It was the true FIFA experience and I was hooked. I love the game of football and even though this was a loss I didn’t care. It was fun and was something I was happy to do for the rest of the day.

So I clicked on find a game again… and nothing. I’ve not been able to play since.

Apparently this problem is localised to South Africa and only occurs on the Xbox One version but that’s what I have and that’s where I live. It’s now been 6 days since I first started trying to get into the MP of FIFA 17 and I’m now giving up. Apparently the matchmaking issues don’t affect the PlayStation 4 version, but we don’t have that, and can only review what we have. Your mileage may vary. If the online multiplayer worked I’d probably be giving this an 8.

Last Updated: October 20, 2016

FIFA 17 (Xbox One)
While the game is amazing at its core, it's beset by infuriating bugs. The Journey shows promise, but drags on too long, becoming a dull grind before it comes to a close. It's a good start for FIFA on its new engine, there are too many kinks that have yet to be worked out.
6.5
FIFA 17 (Xbox One) was reviewed on Xbox One
84 / 100

22 Comments

  1. MakeItLegal

    October 20, 2016 at 15:09

    xbox one getting the heavy end

    Reply

  2. Avithar

    October 20, 2016 at 15:27

    i hear The Journey is a single season… EA should look at making this long

    Reply

    • miaau

      October 20, 2016 at 15:30

      In a single season you go to lower leagues, come back, play in premier league and then play for England? Um, what? Realistic much, of course.

      Reply

      • Skyblue

        October 20, 2016 at 15:32

        It’s called the Jamie Vardy mode

        Reply

    • Geoffrey Tim

      October 20, 2016 at 15:32

      It’s BLOODY LONG. 15 hours long.

      Reply

      • Avithar

        October 20, 2016 at 15:41

        hopefully there is a patch that extends it, then i will consider buying it

        Reply

        • Skyblue

          October 20, 2016 at 15:50

          It’s EA, it’s called a Season Pass and it costs money, so no.

          Reply

          • Avithar

            October 20, 2016 at 15:52

            Season Pass to play the season longer hahaha

          • Skyblue

            October 20, 2016 at 15:57

            Hehe, nothing would surprise me with EA

  3. Skyblue

    October 20, 2016 at 15:29

    Awe Gav, why you mad bro? Liverpool might make top 6 this year :-p

    Reply

    • Gavin Mannion

      October 20, 2016 at 20:47

      Top 6? Please we’re going to be champions this year… It’s our year this year

      Reply

      • Skyblue

        October 20, 2016 at 21:27

        ROFL! The Pool are my second team as I’ve been forced to watch their games (due to my best mate) for the last 20yrs while every year my team finish in the top four and I’m more miserable than he is.

        Reply

        • Gavin Mannion

          October 21, 2016 at 06:48

          Every year I believe it is our year and every year we fall short… doesn’t stop me believing it is our year again this year.. Liverpool is the only thing in my life which I don’t use logic on…

          Reply

  4. z1n

    October 20, 2016 at 15:32

    Two things you’ve mentioned here, unresponsive/inaccurate controls and ref/rule logic, are also quite a problem in a few other sporting titles. The mobile version of FIFA was so frustrating I deleted it. Rugby challenge was pretty cool but also beset with so many of these basic issues.

    I remember playing the older FIFA’s (pc and phone) and not having anywhere near the amount of problems. I fear you are spot on Gavin, with regards to the development compromises. And this is affecting end users, like me, who nearly throws their PC at a wall because it’s a F@K1nG penalty you p035 ref!!

    Reply

  5. Aries

    October 20, 2016 at 16:05

    Actually think the new game engine made the gameplay feel much better and smoother than 16 plus the passing seems fixed. 17 is a huge improvement gameplay wise. The Journey is boring, dont care much for that crap, online much of the same, dont care for paying a sub to play online(PS4 btw).

    Reply

    • Jonah Cash

      October 20, 2016 at 16:57

      It feels a lot better than 16 to me too. They have at least fixed the brick they called a ball in 16 🙂

      Reply

    • Gavin Mannion

      October 20, 2016 at 20:45

      I would like to get my hands on the PS4 version to see if it’s different. But I definitely feel this version is worse than 16 in nearly every sense

      Reply

  6. HvR

    October 20, 2016 at 16:09

    Wanted say SPOILERS!!!

    But who are we kidding it is soccer, it is draw 90% of the time and at the end of the year Liverpool looses.

    Reply

  7. Jonah Cash

    October 20, 2016 at 16:56

    Hahahaha! Playing Fifa 17 on PS4. Don’t have half the issues you are stating here. I have played over 50 games in FUT and have had maybe 5 bad connection games. Overall I am happy with Fifa this year, just don’t try and defend on your own in online games. If the guy plays to his striker and only your back 4 is left, leave all the controls… No seriously leave everything and try and get a midfielder in there!

    Reply

  8. poco

    October 20, 2016 at 22:43

    Please does anyone realize how the defence has been slack, and recovering the ball from an opponent is next to impossible as compared to fifa16 where you hit x and could retrieve the ball. Also why did they not include other African countries in the new fifa like Nigeria and India is on there like really? I don’t know why fifa has not improved on this till now. Any idea if a world cup version of fifa is coming sooon?

    Reply

  9. 40 Insane Frogs

    October 21, 2016 at 12:58

  10. Cl0uds

    October 21, 2016 at 13:22

    Most accurate Fifa 17 review yet

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Check Also

Kwesé is live streaming the 2017 FIFA Interactive World Cup

Kwesé are stepping up their FIFA presence with a live stream of the Internactive World Cup…