Mafia 3 Review 1

Just like its setting, Mafia III sometimes feels like it’s stuck in the past. It often reminded me of open-world games from nearly a decade ago – hampered by the lack of technology required to make diverse, interesting worlds to explore – resulting in often shallow, repetitive gameplay. On the surface that’s exactly what Mafia 3 is, and it’s a shame. Because those who stay the course and dig a little deeper will find a tale deserving of a far greater game that encompasses it.

Mafia III’s problems don’t start until you’re severely hooked to its story though. Its narrative heavy opening does a brilliant job of introducing you to anti-hero Lincoln Clay – a returning Vietnam soldier whose only life outside of the war has been with New Bordeaux’s Black Mob. It’s a crime family in dire straights too, with Lincoln’s arrival setting off a chain of events that set the overarching revenge tale in motion.

Mafia 3 Review 2

“Paint It Black”

Without going into specifics, Mafia III’s opening delivers a compelling reason for Lincoln to undertake his mission, culminating in a beautifully rendered, heart-breaking scene that rounds up the introduction. The use of a documentary-styled format helps keep the tale compelling throughout too, with Lincoln’s actions recounted by the faces you’ll see by your side through your journey. The pseudo interview footage spliced with declassified recordings help make Mafia III feel like a film I’d like to watch – a thought that crossed my mind many times the chore of actually playing bore down on me.

This format would be little without the top of class performances though, a facet of Mafia III which outshines nearly most that try stand next to it. A combination of superb motion capture and varied, gut-wrenchingly good voice acting engrains characters in your memories, and brings them alive in their various roles. Particular monologues stand out from the start and stay with you to the very end, with the superb writing offering up slight hints at events to come while also holding you in suspense. Mafia III sets the bar in this regard, and it’s an act many titles will struggle to follow.

Mafia 3 Review 5

A part of that has to do a lot with the subject matter that Mafia III deals with too. Being set in Southern America in the early 1970s, Mafia 3 never shies away from showing the rampant (and scarily, still very prevalent) racism that existed at the time. Although most of the story revolves around Lincoln and his revenge, there’re elements there that simply would not be able to exist had he been a white protagonist. It’s an added layer that exposes some of the deplorable depths people can sink to in their bigotry, and ironically the downfall of many of Lincoln’s foes.

Walking down the street as Lincoln in different districts yields different results. In the Hollows, an area frequented more by predominately black citizens, Lincoln is greeted with warmth. He’s asked how he is and gives passing helloes – all of which is turned on its head in more affluent districts. The white suburbs of Fresco Fields have the police looking at Lincoln a little closer (made evident by their blue awareness marker growing as you simply walk by), while white citizens will generally scoff at your presence.

Mafia 3 Review 3

“I Wish It Would Rain”

This disparity between white and black areas permeates gameplay in some subtle ways too. Police, for example, will take longer to respond to crimes in the Hollow than in Fresco Fields. Even the dispatcher, which you can clearly hear over an earpiece, changes their tone based on the area you’re in. A shooting in the Hollows might only warrant attention if in officer is passing by, while grand theft auto in more suburban areas has a tangible sense of urgency to responses.

New Bordeaux itself is also a really well put together city of New Orleans’ best beats, stretching from the swampy bayou to the more cultural streets of the French Ward. It’s a pity then that Mafia III’s visual presentation doesn’t really do credit to it’s otherwise exceptional world building. Textures can often appear muddy and draw distances are exceptionally low, leading to cars and people popping into existence right in front of you at times.

Mafia 3 Review 7

Several visual oddities plague the game too, although many don’t have a lasting effect on actual gameplay. At one point a set-piece mission taking place at night had a sudden white glare come over it for a second, while another saw textures outright missing from an area for a few seconds. Near the end of the game the day/night cycle broke too, keeping me in a perpetual night-time storm for hours until I finally reloaded my save. Thankfully Mafia III looks its best on dark, rain slicked streets, but it’s a problem nonetheless.

The same disappointment can’t be expressed over the game’s soundtrack however, which is arguably one of the best features of the entire product. A plethora of classic hits welcomes you every time you get into a car, making the sometimes long journeys across the map (there’s no fast travel for some inexplicable reason) all the more bearable. There’s care taken too when assigning particular songs to moments of intensity, and across the board there’s never a missed beat. Mafia III might not always look the best, but it sounds fantastic all the time.

Mafia 3 Review 6

“A Little Less Conversation”

Playing Mafia III for 30 hours though, was less of an entrancing experience. After the opening you’re quickly shimmied into the bread and butter of gameplay, which involves reclaiming districts from the Italian Mob. Each district has two criminal activities attributed to it, each with a running counter of monetary damage you can inflict on it. Busting up rackets, killing underbosses and torching mob assets all slowly count this value down – until the district boss has to personally appear and deal with you.

While it’s novel at the start, it does not take long for Mafia III to use this loop as a detrimental crutch. Despite the flavour text attempting to differentiate smaller missions within districts, most boil down to simply showing up and firing off a few rounds into the bad guys, and continuing until necessary. The fact that this is repeated without any variation across the game’s nine districts turns progression into an absolutely chore, as you continue slugging it out until the single, district specific story mission.

Mafia 3 Review 8

These unlock when one of the more central characters is ready to be confronted, and offer up the most captivating moments of gameplay that Mafia 3 has to offer. Hanger 13 stretches their creativity here, putting Lincoln in more directed missions that change the way you’d traditionally approach crime rackets. One has you assaulting a boat on the bayou, while another tasks you with planting a tracker on a car being transported on a freighter – only to escape by driving another car off a ramp an back onto the dock.

Those encompass only a handful of the intense, utterly enjoyable story missions that I looked forward to while crawling back a district, only to be disappointed by how frustratingly sparse these moments of brilliance were. Gunplay doesn’t alleviate the monotony either, with most of Mafia III’s standard cover-based action being exactly that – standard. Aiming can be a little floaty at times and far too slow in others, while weapons lack the short of definitive punches that differentiate them.

Mafia 3 Review 9

Assigning districts to your three underbosses unlock new weapons and perks to play around with, but outside of being able to carry more ammunition or health adrenaline shots nothing really changed the way I played. It’s clear that Mafia III benefits players who attempt to play it more subtly, with stealth executions and general sneaking around yielding far more satisfying moment to moment gameplay than the par for the course cover shooting.

It’s made worse still by the inconsistent AI, which doesn’t give enemies much to work with. Often they’ll be content sitting in the same cover position for the entirety of a fight, popping their heads up for easy shots frequently. Other times Sentries will simply try to run past you, or heavier shotgun wielding foes will throw away all sense of self-preservation and walk slowly towards you in the open (and that’s when they’re not running into a wall endlessly). Mafia III is difficult because of how quickly you die, and not because of how enemies can outsmart you.

Mafia 3 Review 4

Mafia III might trudge along to its final conclusion, and it’s a journey that didn’t always feel captivating to stick with, but it’s one that by its close I was happy I had made. For all its many shortcomings, Mafia III still manages to wrap you in a revenge tale begs you to push forward, helped along by a storytelling format that offers up the right amount of suspension and foreshadowing at the right times. It’s not always fun, but Mafia III has a story to tell. And although it requires patience, it’s one that often returns the favour.


Last Updated: October 11, 2016

Mafia III
Mafia III is a flawed game at times, but an equalling captivating one in others. It’s repetitive gameplay loops and standard mechanics hide an engrossing tale grounded by top of the class performances. It’s a tale that pays off in closing, if only just barely.
Mafia III was reviewed on PlayStation 4
68 / 100


  1. What’s the driving like, because that was crap in Mafia 2.

    Otherwise it sounds practically the same – great story, average shooting.


    • TrebZlatan

      October 11, 2016 at 15:51

      It’s just as crap.


    • Avithar

      October 17, 2016 at 11:15

      Mine arrived this morning… Hope the driving is not crappy


    • Avithar

      October 18, 2016 at 14:49

      So i got a few minutes in…Thus far the driving seems to be larger based on LA Noir, the shooting takes some getting use to. Love the cut scenes and the fact there are some actual images from the era (it looks real). also see there is a 2.9GB update (Not a show stopper) Game loaded and played with out it


  2. Dungeon of JJ

    October 11, 2016 at 15:44

    Pity the pc port is shite. Oh what a surprise.


    • Hammersteyn_hates_Raid0

      October 11, 2016 at 16:11

      This is true for most PC ports, so get a console already 😛


      • Dungeon of JJ

        October 11, 2016 at 16:13

        No! I’ll rather die in 60+FPS than live in 30FPS! 😛


        • Hammersteyn_hates_Raid0

          October 12, 2016 at 07:59

          Oh come now, we even have affordable VR headsets and move controllers XD


          • Dungeon of JJ

            October 12, 2016 at 09:09

            Away with your logic!

      • Gr8_Balls_o_Fire

        October 13, 2016 at 09:11

        Not a PS4. They haven’t addressed error CE-34878-0. I even know that damn number off by heart.


        • Hammersteyn_hates_Raid0

          October 13, 2016 at 09:18

          Had to Google that O_o


          • Gr8_Balls_o_Fire

            October 14, 2016 at 09:52

            All of the “solutions” posted don’t work. Tried everything. Eventually had to replace the damn console (luckily under warranty). Not buying PS again.

          • Hammersteyn_hates_Raid0

            October 14, 2016 at 10:06

            That friggin sucks. I’ve played with many, many people. Especially in Destiny but that’s the first I’ve heard of it

  3. Admiral Chief

    October 11, 2016 at 15:48



  4. TrebZlatan

    October 11, 2016 at 15:51

    It’s pretty average and fully agree with you *shocked face* I expected so much more, but guess I’ll have to pretend it’s a 10/10 game since I paid for it.


    • Hammersteyn_hates_Raid0

      October 11, 2016 at 16:12

      I said the same about No Man Sky
      *Cries in the corner


      • JacoZAB

        October 12, 2016 at 06:53

        Same here. I over hyped No Man’s Sky something crazy. I played it for a few days and now it’s just gathering dust


        • Hammersteyn_hates_Raid0

          October 12, 2016 at 07:58

          I still need to finish it, but I’ll wait for an update with more content, else it’s au revoir to NMS


    • Fox1 - Retro

      October 12, 2016 at 09:13

      You should have bought PES 2017 instead.


      • TrebZlatan

        October 12, 2016 at 17:54

        I scored FIFA from a friend for free, so I guess that’s like the same right? Alex Hunter is fa better than Wayne Rooney 😀


  5. HairyEwok

    October 11, 2016 at 16:01

    You know somethings wrong with the games story when Angry Joe goes and says the side stories is more interesting to play than the main story.


  6. Maldy

    October 13, 2016 at 07:15

    Can’t wait until they fix all the bugs on PC version


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check Also

Twelve Minutes Review – Stuck in a Mystery Time Loop

We’ve all experienced deja vu a few times in our lives, but what happens when you ha…