There’s no harm in having a second opinion review for high-profile and potentially divisive Birds of Prey. Seeing as it’s positioned such a Girl Power experience, here’s what one of our woman writers thought:

Remember when Suicide Squad came out and it felt like Warner Bros’ clumsy “late to the party” attempt to replicate the successful Guardians of the Galaxy formula? Tonally disjointed scene jumps as a result of reshoots. Shoehorned-in, distracting music. Even if you didn’t absolutely hate Suicide Squad (I personally didn’t), you had to admit it was a hot mess.

Four years later, though, an apparent second attempt at edgy imitation has produced far better results, and we have a legit “DC Deadpool movie” in the form of Suicide Squad’s spin-off-sequel-thingie, Birds of Prey (and the Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn). Birds of Prey is a high-energy, unquestionably R-rated romp that combines crunchy, satisfying violence with flashes of sparkly golden heart shining through.

In the lead-up to the film’s release, I wasn’t sold. At least in the first trailer, Birds of Prey looked like one of those manic big-screen efforts where the cast is having more fun than the audience, and the latter is expected to get swept up in the energy. That rarely works. Pre-release, the film Birds of Prey seemed too tonally removed from what I expected an adaptation of the comic to be like. Even the character line-up felt more like an attempt to cash in on Harley Quinn’s popularity than strive for any fidelity to the source material.

I’m pleased to report my preconceptions were completely off the mark. The onscreen Birds of Prey IS Birds of Prey. It’s just told from Harley Quinn’s hyper, unbalanced perspective, which actually makes things a lot more interesting.

Like Harley’s pet hyena Bruce, Birds of Prey is a film unleashed. The actors go all-in with their characters. Ewan McGregor’s Black Mask is enjoyably over the top, until his snaps of malice – squirm-inducing in some scenes, especially for female viewers – make you rethink your stance. Meanwhile, Mary Elizabeth Winstead is a scene stealer as the socially awkward Huntress, warped by her unusual upbringing.

Birds of Prey is a brisk 109 minutes, and while the required pace produces some plot wobbles, the film otherwise doesn’t put a foot wrong. Speaking of which, Harley’s combat style is like a dance, and the many fight scenes are beautifully choreographed and coherent. I’m still kind of in shock about how well-put-together the film is – fast and fun, but also very meaty if you apply a magnifying glass to its characters, themes, song choice and settings.

Birds of Prey isn’t a token five-second shot of a bunch of (anti)heroines standing side by side. Put through the costumed hero filter – proving again that superhero movies can be MORE – it’s a legitimate, unlaboured and pioneering tale of female solidarity, and the emancipation of each of these diverse women. Highly recommended.

Last Updated: February 7, 2020

Think of Birds of Prey as DC's Deadpool. It's brutal, brisk fun with a golden heart beneath its colourful-but-tarnished exterior. Some plot niggles aside, it doesn't put a foot wrong, with incredible fight scenes, spot-on performances, and a surprising amount of depth if you feel like digging into the nuances of every well-thought-out scene.
60/ 100


  1. Original Heretic

    February 7, 2020 at 14:41

    What?! Second opinions are allowed?!
    Okay damn, I better go see another doctor about that rash then.


  2. BlinkySparkz

    February 7, 2020 at 20:07

    I really liked that the movie wasn’t so focused on super powers as such, I mean DC has a lot of extraordinary ordinary people, but (to me at least) it feels like most comic-book-based media lately is just always about people with powers. So I appreciated Renee Montoya and Huntress, while they are highly trained and skilled it’s not some super power that makes them great, it’s just themselves. And being great at what they do didn’t take away the struggles and problems they have, it can be comforting to know everyone suffers in their own way.


  3. Tbone187

    February 10, 2020 at 14:27

    I need a third opinion from someone gender fluid 🙂


  4. Stoompot

    February 11, 2020 at 08:03

    The movie flops because muh-diversity.
    They nailed Harley Quinn and Huntress(for the most part sure) but the rest?
    Did they purposefully cast Black Canary as Black Canary?
    Renee Monotoya? Because a lesbian Latino in a comic book is very diverse even though she was in BOP for 5 minutes.
    Cassandra Cain, was never in BOP but she’s Asian so toss her in.
    Diversity Achieved!

    Here’s a small list of more interesting actual BOP members that they could’ve used.
    Batwoman, Lady Blackhawk, Big Barda, Hawkgirl, Manhunter, Black Alice, Power Girl, Vixen, Starling, Katana, Catwoman, Poison Ivy.

    Katana was in Suicide Squad, can’t remember if she died. not that it matters in these movies.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check Also

Rocksteady’s Suicide Squad has Been Delayed Until 2023

According to a Bloomberg report, various sources familiar with the development have said t…