Home Gaming Batman Arkham Knight is a beautiful lie

Batman Arkham Knight is a beautiful lie

3 min read


And I mean that in the sincerest way possible. Sometimes, a flat-out lie is great. Hell, it can be magnificent. Unless you’re a PC gamer that is. And the hottest game of June, Batman Arkham Knight, packs a whopper of a fib. And it’s a better game because of that un-truth.

First up, let me preface this story by mentioning that it has MASSIVE HONKING SPOILERS. Seriously, this is your only warning, so don’t go crying to mommy if you proceed any further. The waffling ends after the amusing picture below, m’kay?


You still here? Good, let’s get this show on the road. So what was the biggest mystery behind Batman Arkham Knight? If you said “The Arkham Knight’s true identity”, then ten points to Pennyworth house. For many months, the entire build-up around the game was centered around this new menace.

A nemesis who knew Batman inside and out, a threat who had created an army specifically trained to neutralise the usual tricks and gadgets that the caped crusader employed in his war on crime. So who the hell was he? The obvious answer, was former Robin Jason Todd.

I mean, c’mon, it just fit. The motivation, the skills, the gadgets. He had everything. And developer Rocksteady was like “nuh uh”. It got ridiculous, to the point where we guessing that anybody from Damien Wayne to Bat-Mite could be under the mysterious helmet.

And that was a bare-faced lie. It was freakin’ Jason Todd the whole time. And that, was a perfect example of misdirection. Because let’s be honest, Jason Todd’s bat-feud wasn’t the real shocker in the game. It was this guy:

The mother-lovin’ clown prince of crime himself. And yes, I know that he was just a hallucination. I know he was all in Batman’s head. But just for that one moment, that one second where you turn around and find the Joker pointing a loaded gun at you, hell, I was shocked.

No one saw that coming. Hell, the majority of your video game audience is clever enough to spot any trope, but show me a person who wasn’t surprised by that one single moment, and I’ll show you a liar in return.

And you have to understand why this particular scene is so damn important. Heroes are defined by their villains, and no single menace mirrors Batman better than the Joker.

The two of them are the yin and yang of comic book partnerships. Two sides of the same coin, a pairing better than when Harry met Sally. And no single person has better portrayed the Joker, than Mark Hamill. His brand of theatrical madness is the clown prince of crime that everybody is familiar with.

Arkham Joker

And ever since his character died in Batman Arkham City, it’s a role that he had barely touched on since. But the wait was worth it. And Batman Arkham City will always go down as the most iconic showdown between the two. Think about it. Think about the history between the two, and then rewatch the ending of the first Bat-sequel:

Powerful stuff. There have been great attempts at using other voice actors to fill that role in the years between Arkham City and Arkham Knight. Troy Baker did a great impersonation of Mark Hamill voicing the Joker.

Brent “Data” Spiner was a cool Joker in Young Justice. Michael Emerson was downright creepy in The Dark Knight Returns Part 2. But Mark Hamill is the Joker. And being slapped in the face with some Joker Toxin just as Arkham Knight was getting into gear was the surprise of the year.

The Arkham Knight may have been a red herring, but it’s a fish that clearly had some Joker influences on it. Well played Rocksteady.

Last Updated: July 20, 2015


  1. Werner Morris

    July 20, 2015 at 15:13

    This is an opinion piece by the author indicated and does not represent the views of the publication or its staff. – Disclaimer to not be donnered.


  2. David

    July 20, 2015 at 15:17

    I really enjoyed how they went about the Red Hood – I mean, if they came right out and said they were doing the Red Hood arch it would’ve taken a lot of punch out of it. And it did lead to some groans by some when it we discussed but given enough time one realises there was literally no other way to do this.

    Yes, it was obvious but still it was a very creative way to be obvious and still get the narrative honed. 😀

    As for the joker, yes – he is essential to the Batman, as a mirror and I get your view of the red herring but the biggest lie was this:

    Scarecrow is actually a worthy opponent… cause he wasn’t, isn’t and never will be. 😛


  3. Brady miaau

    July 20, 2015 at 15:44

    Spoiler, much? I mean, sheesh? Joker dies at the end of Arkham City? What? Come on!

    Sigh. Ok, I hardly have the heart today, Darryn, but I tried.


    • Katherine

      July 21, 2015 at 05:26

      Hey. They did gave you a warning to be fair


  4. Lollies the Laughing Lollipop

    July 20, 2015 at 15:48

    to be honest, Great Game.. Loved it got about 97% completion just couldnt give a flying Batfuck about the last 100 or so riddler trophies. BUTT(_!_) I feel do feel that the “Twists” where bit easy to figure out. I knew AK was JT from about 3 lines of dialog in to his chat with Batsy..


  5. SargonTheBatpandaOfTI5

    July 20, 2015 at 16:37

    Love the addition of the “opinion piece” statement at the end of the article. Either it’s new (from the occurrence of last week I guess) or I’ve just never noticed it before?


  6. Darth

    July 20, 2015 at 16:51

    Opinion piece my foot: Mark Hamill IS the best joker. Hands down. Better than Ledger. Better than Romero. Certainly better than Nicholson. I can’t think of a single more definitve portrayal.


    • DJ Homeless Mike

      July 20, 2015 at 23:57

      I’d really like to see on online poll for this! Usually Hamill is not included.


  7. Adrian Bachnivsky

    July 20, 2015 at 16:53

    Lazygamer, lazy article.


  8. Jonah Cash

    July 20, 2015 at 17:03

    Haven’t even bought the game, so will give this article a skip 🙂


  9. Nikola

    July 21, 2015 at 10:17

    I was going to get the DLC with the Batgirl but after reading the reviews I think I might give it a skip it’s only an hour long….for like over R100 no thanks


  10. HaVoK6

    July 21, 2015 at 10:19

    Am I the only one who hated the Riddler sections to this game 🙁 Oh yes and the damn batTank killing drones section as well


    • Nikola

      July 21, 2015 at 10:21

      I enjoyed them quite a bit but then again I finished all the riddles and trophy to unlock that knigtfall portocol ending:)


      • HaVoK6

        July 21, 2015 at 11:04

        *sigh* I just want to punch criminals in the face 🙂


  11. Chule Gcanga

    July 21, 2015 at 10:33

    Yep, Joker was a bigger & more pleasant surprise then Jason. Dig that it was intellectual more then a physical enemy… love this game, Still have to collect like trillion Riddler trophies to finish the game proper -_- …..


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check Also

Rocksteady’s Suicide Squad has Been Delayed Until 2023

According to a Bloomberg report, various sources familiar with the development have said t…