Remember a while back, when a little bit of a controversy got kicked up because Microsoft decided to drop the processor from their Kinect hardware?
The internet went wild and started to blame the lack of a dedicated processor for the input lag seen on early units of the then Project Natal demos that were doing the rounds. So why was the processor dropped then? An evil scheme to screw gamers and save money to buy more yachts?
The latest videos on display of the Kinect units show that the input delay is very much within acceptable range, regardless of the fact that the Xbox 360 is now handling all of the processing.
According to Microsoft, the reason that the processor was dropped was simply because its power was just “not needed”. They say that Kinect only uses 1% of the Xbox 360’s processing power however, I bet that if it still had a processor they would be telling us that it was powerful enough to control an intergalactic spaceship, but hey, that’s just me.
Our favorite odd weirdo in charge of the Kinect project, Kudo Tsunoda had the following things to say on the matter:
“We didn’t know how much processing Kinect was going to take at the start of development,”
“Obviously you don’t want to lose any of the things that are important to Xbox customers. Graphic fidelity is something that Xbox has always been known for, and you want to make sure that you still hit that level.
“Forza is a graphical showpiece, and we had Forza with Kinect at E3… the graphic fidelity has actually improved in some areas from what they shipped with Forza 3. It’s still running at 60 FPS and it’s supporting Kinect, so there’s just no need to have that extra processor.”
He also went on to answer the question of why the Kinect initially tracked 50 points and why it now only tracks 20:
“As you start building the stuff, you’re like: ‘Wow, to track everything in the human body we can do less points. That’s just normal game development. Anything you do with games, you want the processing power to be used as efficiently as possible to get the experience that you want.”
So in conclusion, Microsoft are basically saying that the changes made to Kinect were basically down to optimization and streamlining. Truth is that we still don’t actually have any solid proof that the Kinect would have been any quicker using its own processor.
It’s also worth a mention that if the Kinect did have the extra hardware, it would have been even more expensive and the way that its pricing is looking already, it would have resulted in nothing but a pure flop for them.
Source: CVG
Last Updated: September 30, 2010
Fox1
September 30, 2010 at 11:33
So back to that Forza talk… :ninja:
darthdad
September 30, 2010 at 12:14
So they’re basically saying, ” We’ve made it less powerful and not as accurate, because we feel it’s good enough.” :ninja:
lans
September 30, 2010 at 12:16
whats a forza?
Fox1
September 30, 2010 at 12:28
Well the left-out chip could have being a bottleneck to a fully fledged tri-core cpu.
James of the Jungle
September 30, 2010 at 12:47
It’s supposedly in the same league as Gran Turismo, but unlike GT, you grow tired of it very easily. :blush:
lans
September 30, 2010 at 13:16
lol
easy
September 30, 2010 at 13:46
all they saying is, that if they pursued the initial specs, it would’ve have been prohibitively expensive.
don’t reckon it worked that, it’s still too expensive for just a wiggle wagger device.
doobiwan
September 30, 2010 at 15:30
But unlike GT it has actually shipped a few releases some time in the last decade 😉
James of the Jungle
September 30, 2010 at 16:34
I still have a copy of Tourist Trophy (PS2), sniff…
James of the Jungle
September 30, 2010 at 16:44
WOW! I just discovered that Kudo Tsunoda was responsible for the travesty that is Def Jam Icon. Kudo single-handedly destroyed the Def Jam games (how could they go so wrong after Fight for NY?).
Now I know with 100% certainty that Kinect will suck.
david952
October 30, 2010 at 09:36
processor was dropped hmm.. think about that for questionable amount of time.
?why did ms take out the chip
well the answer to this is more products for the kinect it self…
it is all about selling with ms and with ms nothing is FREE!!!