Should games get extra points for innovation

2 min read
5

Mirror's Edge

Innovation, it’s the word that defines this generation in either a positive or negative light.

You are either on the side that feels this generation is full of innovation from the Blu-Ray playing PS3, to the motion controlling Wii to the Internet integrated 360.

Or you are on the side negative side that feels the Wii is a toy, Blu-Ray is a waste and the 360 didn’t innovate a single thing in this iteration.

But the question being raised by the Guardian newspaper is whether or not we should reward games for being innovative, in particular Mirror’s Edge.

Can we forgive the dodgy control scheme, linear gameplay and short story purely because they are pushing new boundaries and attempting to truly innovate? I honestly believe we can and should. However Destructoid has a valid counter argument where they rightly point out that crap games have been pointing to innovation to try and save themselves.

Step forward Space Giraffe, Lair and Too Human…

So how should we handle ‘innovation’ in this generation?

I think the answer is pretty straight forward to be honest, if it’s fun and adds to the overall experience then it’s a good thing and the game gets extra credits (ala Mirror’s Edge or LBP) if the innovation is crap then the game gets marked down for it.

However I couldn’t end this without pointing out that I honestly feel the author of the Guardian article is treading a thin line when he says

Games are games, true enough. They’re not artistic statements in the same way as movies are, but they are creative works and creativity needs to be nurtured.

Granted games are not the same as movies but I do feel they are more of an artistic statement than any movie has ever been. A game sits perfectly between a movie and a book where we get to get the visual effect of a movie with the thought provoking impact of a book.

Last Updated: November 17, 2008

Check Also

SUPERGIRL's James Olsen gets his own super-suit as Guardian

James Olsen is suiting up to become the masked vigilante Guardian in Supergirl …